Project the “Plantation Dance, South Carolina, ca. 1785-1795” painting at the front of the class and tell students it was likely painted by John Rose, a South Carolina slave plantation owner, in the 1780s or 1790s. (Note: The painting was not titled originally, and is often labeled as “The Old Plantation.”) Distribute the Resistance in Plantation Art handout and give students 5-10 minutes to do Part 1, a silent, individual observation of the painting in which they list and briefly describe everything they see in the image. Prompt them to note specific details (ex. What are people holding? How are they standing? Where are the buildings in relation to the people?, etc.)
Then lead a brief class discussion in which you review students’ observations and ensure everyone is working from a shared set of facts about what they see in the painting. You may wish to use the Slavery Images description of “Plantation Dance, South Carolina, ca. 1785-1795”) to help clarify specific elements, focusing on people, instruments, clothing, and the buildings.
Next, remind students that John Rose, a white plantation owner, likely painted the image. How does the image reflect Rose’s (or, more generally, white plantation owners’) perspective? Students should identify the bright colors, happy faces, and bucolic setting as imagery that idealized the slave plantation and erased its brutality.
Introduce what it means to “Read against the Grain” of a historical source. Reading against the grain is the process of looking at a historical document to find evidence the creator perhaps did not intend to reveal. We treat the document like an investigation and search it for unintended clues, illuminating details, and “accidental” information regarding the lives, agency, and choices of people in the past. This process is especially important when there are archival silences in the historical record.
Divide the class into small groups and have them complete Part 2 of the handout in which they “read against the grain” of the painting to identify how it reveals enslaved peoples’ acts of resistance. After students have completed Part 2, bring the class back together and review. Conclude by having students write a personal reflection based on the following prompts about enslaved resistance and archival silences:
- What specific truths about the people in this painting still remain unavailable to us because we lack a record written by the community/dancers themselves? (Ex. their names, their songs, and their reasons for dancing.)
- How does this “archival silence” affect our ability to understand the full history of enslaved resistance? What kinds of historical sources (whether they exist or not) would help us gain greater insight?