Spreading the Abolitionist Message

Unit

Spreading the Abolitionist Message

Years: 1830-1860s

Culture & Community

Economy & Society

Freedom & Equal Rights

Historical Events, Movements, and Figures

01

Prior Knowledge

Prior to this lesson, students should be aware of the institution of slavery in the United States and its economic implications on the American economy in both the North and the South. Students should also be aware of the conflicting ideals of founding documents such as the Declaration of Independence and the actual lived experiences of African Americans. Finally, students should be knowledgeable about the variety of ways that enslaved African Americans sought freedom in response to this injustice.

You may want to consider after teaching this lesson:

  • Events like the Missouri Compromise, the Compromise of 1850, the Fugitive Slave Law, and the Kansas Nebraska Act would eventually lead the country to engage in the Civil War.

02

Student Objectives

  • Define propaganda and examples of how it can be effectively used across audiences
  • Compare and contrast the merits and relative success of propaganda techniques used by abolitionists in an effort to end the institution of slavery
  • Identify the impact of propaganda techniques on social issues both in the past and present day
Show more

03

Organizing Idea

Abolitionists are examples of some of the earliest social justice activists in American history who worked towards ending slavery. Propaganda, which refers to information that is spread with the aim of promoting a particular cause or point of view, was a frequent tool used by abolitionists in their fight. While abolitionists often addressed audiences through published essays or public speaking engagements, they also used many other venues and approaches to issue their calls for action. While the efforts of abolitionists may not have represented the same risks as other approaches, the sources in this unit show that being an activist took many different successful forms during this period. Further, the approaches led to modern day implications for how we use propaganda today to popularize social issues and inequities.

Show more

04

Teacher Context

The founding of the United States contained a fundamental paradox between the ideals professed by founding documents such as the Declaration of Independence and the actual lived reality for African Americans. While it was stated that all men are created equally and have rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness the institution of slavery  refuted that. And as the Southern economy was built on the foundation of slavery and Northern states also benefited from it economically, there was for many no impetus to address this discrepancy.  

Abolitionists are examples of some of the earliest social justice activists in American history who did work towards ending slavery. The Abolition Movement started with a focus on abolishing the international slave trade between the 1790s and 1808. Once this goal was accomplished, activists focused their attention on ending slavery entirely throughout the nation. 

Abolitionists were very active in the years leading up to the Civil War, but they made up a minority opinion and it was often very dangerous to espouse ideas of equality. While, the highest urgency and largest scope of efforts to seek and make freedom attainable resided within free and enslaved Black Americans, White abolitionists, such as William Lloyd Garrison, often influenced by Christian morals made it an interracial movement.

Abolitionists took action in a multitude of ways. For example, some abolitionists risked their lives by helping enslaved Americans escape from slavery through the Underground Railroad. While others wrote and published their stories and opinions about the institution of slavery evoking passionate responses in their audiences. David Walker, Harriet Jacobs, Sojourner Truth, Frederick Douglass and William Lloyd Garrison all had seminal works or speeches during this time that impacted a great many Americans’ understanding of the brutality of slavery as well as how the institution of slavery was contrary to  the American values of freedom and democracy.

Many abolitionists however were not able or willing to commit to such dangerous or public acts of support and found other ways to raise awareness to turn the tide of public opinion.  In contrast to potentially dangerous actions like sheltering people escaping from slavery, the publication and sharing of books, newspapers,  images and songs could easily be incorporated into a person’s private life. These materials were still able to express the horrors of slavery, but targeted a larger audience including children and youth and illiterate adults, to garner greater public support. Further, readers, people who read aloud to groups in barbershops, churches and other places, also reached those who could not read. 

As abolitionists began finding new and unique ways to reach their intended audiences, the country was beginning to show major signs of strain over the issue of slavery. Many abolitionists began to understand that war might be the only way to abolish the institution of slavery in the United States. Events like the Missouri Compromise, the Compromise of 1850, the Fugitive Slave Law, and the Kansas Nebraska Act would eventually lead the country to engage in the Civil War.

References & Further Resources

If you would like to learn more about the language of slavery, the National Park Service has a wonderful resource you can access- https://www.nps.gov/subjects/undergroundrailroad/language-of-slavery.htm

Barnes, Michael Randall (2021). Positive Propaganda and The Pragmatics of Protest. In Brandon Hogan, Michael Cholbi, Alex Madva & Benjamin S. Yost (eds.), The Movement for Black Lives: Philosophical Perspectives. Oxford: Oxford University Press. pp. 139-159.

Cameron, Christopher. The Abolitionist Movement: Documents Decoded. United States: ABC-CLIO, 2014.

Douglass, Frederick. Narrative of the life of Frederick Douglass: An American slave, written by himself. Harvard University Press, 2009.

Fox-Amato, Matthew. Exposing Slavery: Photography, Human Bondage, and the Birth of Modern Visual Politics in America. Oxford University Press, 2019.

Harrold, Stanley. American abolitionists. Routledge, 2014.

Jeffrey, Julie Roy. The great silent army of abolitionism: Ordinary women in the antislavery movement. Univ of North Carolina Press, 1998.

Lowance, Mason, ed. Against Slavery: An Abolitionist Reader. Penguin, 2000.

Mayer, Henry. All on fire: William Lloyd Garrison and the abolition of slavery. WW Norton & Company, 2008.

Masur, Kate. Until Justice Be Done: America’s First Civil Rights Movement, from the Revolution to Reconstruction. WW Norton & Company, 2021.

Sinha, Manisha. The slave’s cause: A history of abolition. Yale University Press, 2016.

Spires, Derrick R. The Practice of Citizenship: Black Politics and Print Culture in the Early United States. University of Pennsylvania Press, 2019.

Stowe, Harriet Beecher. Uncle Tom’s Cabin: 1852. Tauchnitz, 1852.

Williams, R. Owen. Encyclopedia of Antislavery and Abolition [Two Volumes]. United Kingdom: Greenwood Press, 2006.

Abolition.  African American Mosaic.  American Memory Collection.  Library of Congress, Washington. D.C. www.loc.gov/exhibits/african/afam005.html

From Slavery to Freedom: the African American Pamphlet Collection, 1824-1909.  American Memory Collection, Library of Congress, Washington, D.C. http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/aapchtml/aapchome.html

Slavery and Abolition. Guide to Primary Sources. Boston Public Library. Boston, MA. https://guides.bpl.org/primarysources/slaveryandabolition

Abolition. Resources “The Age of Reform”. TeachUShistory.org. American Antiquarian Society. Worcester, MA. https://www.teachushistory.org/second-great-awakening-age-reform/resources Scroll down a little ways to “Abolition” for an incredible collection of primary sources.

Show more

05

Teacher Tips

Abolitionists are examples of some of the earliest social justice activists in American history.  It is important to help students understand that the antislavery movement was interracial and diverse. African Americans clearly had the most urgency for freedom and equality and as such, both free and enslaved African Americans, created, led and sustained the movement. Yet,  exploring the ways that abolitionists worked to spread their message is also a chance to understand and stress that while most White Americans did accept the institution of slavery as a “necessary evil”, there was a small, but passionate, group who understood that the institution of slavery was contrary to  the American values of freedom and democracy. 

It is important throughout this unit to keep in mind your choice of vocabulary in describing African Americans during this period in history. For example, there are many sources which use the historical term “fugitive” to describe an enslaved person that has “escaped” or “run away”. There is a growing movement to recognize the power of words historians and teachers use in their work.  In the case of “fugitive slaves” an alternative is to adopt the term “freedom seeker.” This shift in vocabulary moves the focus away from an association with criminal behavior to a recognition that enslaved people were not criminals, but rather were trying to escape a cruel and unjust system. If you would like to learn more about the language of slavery, the National Park Service has a wonderful resource you can access through the Further Resources in this unit. 

Several of the sources in this lesson also contain racist language or images that may be disturbing to students. It is imperative that these be shared with students with great care, as they can trigger painful emotions in students, such as anger, sadness, fear, and shame. African American students may feel that their identity is under attack. Be sure to create or revisit classroom expectations for behavior that are grounded in respect and empathy for all and provide clear expectations for how students should engage with this content. It is also important to inform students before sharing any potentially disturbing source materials. Offer a clear rationale for why you are sharing the source and allow individual students to opt out of engaging with the source- offering them a meaningful alternative activity. 

Many of the primary sources will also use words that students may be unfamiliar with. Provide access to a dictionary to encourage students to look up words that they do not know.

Show more

06

Student Context

Abolitionists as the name implies strive for the complete eradication of practices rather than incremental reforms. In the 18th and 19th century, abolitionists who were advocates for the abolition of slavery took action in a multitude of ways. There were abolitionists that risked their lives by helping those enslaved seek freedom through the Underground Railroad. While others publicly wrote or spoke out against slavery. By identifying key venues in order to issue their calls for action a wider audience could be reached. 

There were countless other abolitionists that were unable to commit to such dangerous or public acts of support that were still an important part of the movement. Sharing songs, articles, art and even the act of reading aloud for those who were unable to were efforts that could easily be incorporated into a person’s private life. These types of tactics were not only successful in the abolition movement but have also since been utilized in other social justice causes because of the wider audiences they were able to reach.

Show more

07

Key Questions

01.

What groups of Americans did abolitionists try to attract to their antislavery message?

02.

How effective might these materials have been for promoting an antislavery message and encouraging Americans to adopt an abolitionist perspective?

08

Activities & Sources

Select the activities and sources you would like to include in the student view and click “Launch Student View.”

It is highly recommended that you review the Teaching Tips and sources before selecting the activities to best meet the needs and readiness of your students. Activities may utilize resources or primary sources that contain historical expressions of racism, outdated language or racial slurs.

Discussion of “Propaganda” 30 mins

This unit’s primary sources are considered propaganda. This activity explores the use of the term propaganda and assesses it as a social activist tool both past and present.

  • First, ask the students to define “propaganda.” 
  • Build on or write out the definition of propaganda for students to view and reference during this unit. 

Propaganda refers to information used to promote or publicize a particular political cause or point of view. Propaganda can take various forms, such as posters, advertisements, speeches, or social media campaigns, and it is commonly used by governments, organizations, or individuals to influence public opinion or behavior.

  • Ask students to give examples of propaganda they have learned about or observed. Some examples might include: military recruitment ads, all variety of advertisements for consumers, war posters such as the iconic Rosie the Riveter or Uncle Sam posters of WWII. 
  • Read aloud of provide this brief overview to students:

Historians often refer to the materials that abolitionists produced as “propaganda.” This presents an interesting interpretation to the materials because typically, the term propaganda carries a negative connotation around – the intent to mislead the audience. Yet, not all propaganda is created equally. There are many examples of “positive propaganda” that complicate the typical definition. For example, governments use propaganda to promote healthy habits such as no smoking campaigns and attempting to reduce drunk driving. Propaganda can also be used to raise morale during wartime. More recently, there has also been a movement by scholars to consider protest propaganda such as Black Lives Matter as positive propaganda due to its goal in creating a more equitable society. 

Analysis of “Abolitionist Propaganda”- Songs 60 Minutes

  • Share the following introduction to the activity with students.

Music is a language that crosses race and class reaching a wide range of audience. Songs are memorable and can be retold over and over again. In the early to mid-1800s, printing materials would have been expensive and many Americans  were not literate. Songs could be memorized and repeated regardless of literacy. Songs could also be used in informal settings to share important messages. For these reasons, songs were an important tool in spreading the abolitionist message. Many of these songs are used to uplift abolitionists in their work towards ending slavery. They could appeal to existing abolitionists or to Americans who want to be a part of something greater than themselves. This was true across regions as even enslaved populations could share songs in secret and the religious undertones were intended to be hopeful. 

  • Break the class into three larger groups or multiple groups of three and ask each group/student to read and analyze one song.
  • Students should then respond to the following questions orally or in writing in preparation for a small group or whole class discussion.  
  • What is the title of your song and what is it about?
  • To whom (position, region, religion, etc.) may this song have appealed most? Why?
  • How might this song have made the people listening feel or act? 
  • What words or lines from the song stood out the most to you? Why?
  • Lead a whole group discussion answering the following:
  • Do these songs fit the definition of propaganda?
    • Propaganda refers to information used to promote or publicize a particular political cause or point of view. Propaganda can take various forms, such as posters, advertisements, speeches, or social media campaigns, and it is commonly used by governments, organizations, or individuals to influence public opinion or behavior.
  • Why would it be important in a struggle against the institution of slavery to use popular songs, or short rhymes to gather support from the general public?
  • Can you think of songs that are similar or that could be considered propaganda in other periods of history or today?
  • If students have difficulty responding or if you want to provide additional information you can close with this 

The songs we read today were meant to evoke emotion from their audience. Songs like “I am an Abolitionist” might make someone feel proud of their identity and for fighting against slavery. The songs were intended to inspire the listener to act and protest the laws that held African Americans in bondage. They might also have inspired a feeling of righteousness through the religious overtones. A song like “Ye Sons of Freemen” might have evoked excitement and even anger with lines referring to burning down plantations. Many of the lyrics might have also provoked a feeling of injustice in the violence and unfairness that the system of slavery produces. 

We have many injustices that have been present in our society in the  twentieth and twenty-first century. More recent examples of propaganda songs include antiwar music from the 1970s from artists such as Bob Dylan and Marvin Gay, anti-police/anti-government groups such as Rage Against the Machine and N.W.A  in the 1990s, and more recent examples such as John Legend and Common’s song “Glory” in 2015.

Analysis of “Abolitionist Propaganda”-Images & Broadsides 45-60 mins

Distribute the following documents at work stations around the room. 

Allow students to move through the stations, to meet your time constraints,  but it is recommended to have at least 8-10 minutes per station. Students, should consider the following questions as they analyze the documents:

  • What is most compelling to you about this document?  What word(s), image or ideal is the most powerful?
  • In what ways could this document be disseminated?  Who would use it and in what ways?  Is it unique?  How?  Think in terms of design and content.
  • How does this document differ from a speech given to a group at an antislavery meeting?  How might the audience differ?

Analysis of “Abolitionist Propaganda”-Children & Youth Publications

Distribute The Slave’s Friend Print 1, 1836 and The Slave’s Friend Print 2, 1837. Ask students to look for clues that point to how these sources may differ from other sources they have examined (ex. large print, states “little readers”, large image, how family is depicted positively- literate and loving).

After a brief discussion, explain to students that The Slave’s Friend was a periodical written for children, whereas as many of the other sources have been geared to adult audiences. This periodical was published from 1836-1838 by the American Anti-Slavery Society.

Discuss with students the following:

  • What would the benefit be of focusing on children and youth?
  • In what ways could children and youth respond to this source that could positively impact change?

Next, provide resources or allow students independently or in small groups to use learned research skills to find and discuss the following:

  • Identify a modern movement and/or social justice initiative focused on equal rights and current related text or image “propaganda” that is focused on children and youth. 
  • Have students share their findings with the whole class and discuss
    • What similarities or differences are there between the example and The Slave’s Friend?
    • What would the benefit be of focusing this issue on children and youth?
    • In what ways could children and youth respond to this source that could positively impact change?

Performance Task: Opinion Essay

Students should select one source covered in this unit that they feel would have been highly effective in bringing about an end to the institution of slavery. 

Students should plan and write an essay that includes details about the source (creator, audience, dissemination method, outcome, etc.) and the reasons for their opinion.

Performance Task: Music as a Tool for Change

To make a connection to today, students can choose a past or contemporary social justice issue and identify a song related to that movement. Ask students to analyze the lyrics and compare and contrast the modern piece they choose with one of the abolitionist songs from Activity 2.

Students can present their findings as a poster or presentation that allows their classmates to hear or read the  

Be mindful for student review and presentation that some songs may have parental advisory warnings that should be considered based on age.

Please login or sign up to access the student view functions.